Revisiting just war theory, cambridge university press, 2015, 272pp. The ammonites were not pacifists meridian magazine. Find all the books, read about the author, and more. Nov 01, 2011 pacifism in japan contains eight essays which deal, among other things, with such outstanding figures as uchimura kanzo and kagawa toyohiko. The best place to begin an analysis of pacifism is with the absolutist argument that all forms of violence, war, andor killing are unconditionally wrong. Integrating literature with philosophy in an innovative way, this unique anthology uses literary works to enliven and make concrete the.
Christian pacifism is the theological and ethical position that any form of violence is incompatible with the christian faith. Philosophical analysis is the techniques typically used by philosophers in the analytic tradition that involve breaking down i. There is no point in them, they exist as a bad corruption result and to bait not so bright people into wasting jewel slots instead of using frenzy with snakebite. In a world riven with conflict, violence and war, this book proposes a philosophical defense of pacifism. Analytic philosophy, with its changing views of philosophical analysis, is a trail of. Pacifism maxim that war is wrong as killing is wrong belongs to the primary theory virtues that the paper will attempt to visualize in sections of absolute, deontological, and consequentialist. Nor is pacifism best understood as a singular or monistic concept. Philosophical analysis semantic scholar the dawn of analysis as a selfconscious philosophical approach. I have left those references in partly simply because they reflect the thinking going on in just war circles when i wrote the paper.
Jan narveson phd philosoph harvard, 1961 university. The result is new moral clarity and insight in both areas, especially regarding the moral treatment due to civilians by purveyors of military violence. But miller is concerned not so much with defending pacifism as he is with sparring with narveson. Readings in ethical issues, second edition, opens with an extensive twochapter introduction to moral reasoning and moral theories that provides students with the. In this new edition of from warism to pacifism, cady continues to expose the pervasive, subconscious warism that is the dominant ideology in modern western culture. Kissinger in the nixon white house susan faludi, stiffed anything by john pilger.
Philosophical discussions of pacifism have clarified the concept by distinguishing. Written in a nontechnical style, the book features reallife examples from contemporary wars and applies a variety of approaches ranging from traditional pacifism and human rights to international. Contemporary moral arguments readings in biggerbooks. Although the emphasis on pacifism as an antiwar doctrine is the focus of this article, the other nuances of the theory need to be noted. Realism and pacifism year 11 gcse religious education. Pacifism may be based on moral principles a deontological view or pragmatism a consequentialist view. As he explained in why men fight, the book he composed while in prison.
Corlett goes in for careful analysis, and doesnt flinch at conclusions that might be unwelcome to some. Practical christian pacifism is grounded in faithfulness and hope, but also in realism. In this carefully argued work, stephen nathanson has brought together two areas, terrorism and the ethics of war, too often treated separately. Judgment and opinion, the international tribunal, nuremberg, germany. Anscombes war and murder and jan narveson s pacifism. Pacifism is a most comprehensible, accessible and wellargued work on the philosophy of war. Pacifism is opposition to war, militarism or violence. Contemporary moral arguments paperback lewis vaughn.
Readings in ethical issues,second edition, opens with an extensive twochapter introduction to moral reasoning and moral theories that provides students with. It provides not only a moral basis for dealing with conflicts but a framework within which to carry on the vital task of building structures that can eventually eliminate war and its causes. But pacifism is not best understood as a negative claim. This book is the culmination of over 15 years of research on terrorism, secession, and related concepts such as the obligation to obey the law, pacifism, civil disobedience, nonviolent direct action, political violence, revolution, and assassination. Pacifism covers a spectrum of views ranging from the belief that international disputes can and should be peacefully resolved, to absolute opposition to the use of violence, or even force, under any circumstances.
It is sincerely hoped that the content of this book is construed as an ethical and philosophical attempt to advance human understanding of some. A related term is ahimsa to do no harm, which is a core philosophy in indian religions such as hinduism, buddhism, and jainism. Arguments for pacifism the cost of war is too great. This is an updated edition of an older classic that remains relevant today. Pacifism is seen more than opposition to violence and war. Pacifism is also closely connected with movements for international disarmament. An introduction to philosophical analysis 4th edition 97802663052. Holmes introduced the notion of conditional pacifism, the view that one can morally and rationally oppose specific wars or specific sorts or war without adopting absolute pacifism. Lewis vaughn is the author or coauthor of several books, including philosophy here and now 2012, bioethics, second edition 2012, the power of critical thinking, fourth edition 2012, and great philosophical arguments 2011, all published by oxford university press. Such a dogmatic and negative formulation of pacifism does leave us with pacifism as a morally problematic position. The appalling loss of life, the significant economic costs, the destruction of physical and social infrastructure, the depletion of natural resources, and the provision to rebuild makes the cost of war too high. Pacifism may entail the belief that the waging of war by a state and the participation in war by an individual are absolutely wrong, under any circumstances. Minstrels of peace is a remarkable study, one that should be bought for every library.
A philosophical analysis, ethics, lxxv, 4 july 1965. The problem of abortion and the doctrine of double effect, by p. Pacifism is the opposition to war or violence as a means of settling disputes. White manages to infuse into his discussion of pacifism the gentleness of deliberation, allowing space for readers to join him in his journey through the subject. A philosophy of nonviolence and millions of other books are available for amazon kindle. It makes numerous references to the soviet union that are obviously now out of date. View entire discussion 11 comments more posts from the pathofexile community. Jan does research in social and political philosophy, applied philosophy and ethics. Varieties of contingent pacifism in war ucsd philosophy. On this view, which can be called absolute pacifism, waging war is always. Jan narveson currently works at the philosophy retired, university of waterloo. It argues that there is a moral presumption against war and unless that presumption is defeated, war is unjustified.
The standard definition of pacifism, on the other hand the rejection of all war as a matter of moral principle has clear conceptual boundaries and thus is of genuine philosophical interest. Pacifism is a transformative philosophy with wide ranging implications. This is a book that will challenge the serious reader, indeed. A new chapter on war and terrorism, with three new readings. Immediately download the pacifism summary, chapterbychapter analysis, book notes, essays, quotes, character descriptions, lesson plans, and more everything you need for studying or teaching pacifism. Pacifism for many means an antiwar stance, but pacifism can also be construed as a broader theory incorporating doctrines of nonviolence, passive resistance, and moral purity.
Sep 03, 2010 realizing that he could not intellectually defend the notions of justwar theory, he found that he was a reluctant pacifist. There are different sorts and degrees of pacifism, but they all include the view that war and violence are unjustified and that conflicts should be settled in a peaceful way. Perhaps the most famous use of the word pacifism is found in the sermon on the mount, where jesus. Such prudential pacifism is based upon costbenefit analyses. In the ancient world, war was taken for granted as a. Pacifism covers an array of views and there are many subcategories of pacifism, some of which i will cover, but the main definition of the word pacifism is the opposition to war andor violence. May 26, 2012 kate millett, the politics of cruelty alexandr solzhenitsyn, the gulag archipelago martin amis, koba the dread seymour hersh, the price of power. Varieties of contingent pacifism in war saba bazargan.
The acorn philosophical studies in pacifism and nonviolence. Other countries followed, and societies were established in france and switzerland not long afterward. If you have access to this journal as a benefit of membership in the sponsoring organization, log in through the member link in the right column. Ideal for introductory ethics courses, the moral life. Leading philosopher of nonviolence robert holmes contends that neither. Terrorism and the ethics of war by stephen nathanson. Issues of selfdefense, preemptive war, torture, pacifism, terrorism, and many more are central to the readings in this book. Excellent philosophical treatments of a pacifist position can be found in richard holmes, on war and morality princeton. Their main page for book sales and book descriptions has links to several sections including. Pacifism is the opposition to war or violence as a means of settling disputes or gaining advantage. Reviewed by jan narveson, university of waterloo in this new book, larry may develops and defends what he claims is a special and new outlook on war.
The idea is complicated by the fact that peace is a family resemblance term. Two renowned critical essays on pacifism, both reprinted in r. Georgia united states supreme court the just war joseph mckenna war and murder g. It is really a history of the british and american peace churches in the 20th century, so the book covers quakers and mennonite conscientious objectors in great detail without too much attention to similar movements elsewhere in the world. The cold warin which the united states and the ussr did not shed each others bloodwas still. In a companion volume to pacifism in the united states, peter brock surveys the history of the pacifist movement in europe from the beginning of the christian era to the first world war. In this, the first major philosophical study of contingent pacifism, larry may offers a new account of pacifism from within the just war tradition. Selections from martha minow, between vengeance and forgiveness 1999. Christian pacifists state that jesus himself was a pacifist who taught and practiced pacifism and that his followers must do likewise. Taking a unique approach that emphasizes careful reasoning, this cuttingedge reader is structured around twentyseven landmark arguments that have provoked heated debates on current ethical issues. I will try to defend the importance of pacifism as an integral part of war as such, pacifism as a requisite of war ought to. Pacifism s popularity rests on confusions about what the doctrine really is. Of all published articles, the following were the most read within the past 12 months.
Pacifism covers a spectrum of views ranging from the belief that international disputes can and should be peacefully resolved. Other sources for similar books are the fellowship of reconciliation, box 271, nyack, ny 10960. Pacifism in the nineteenth century modern pacifism began early in the 19th cent. Ted grimsrud please note that this essay was written in 1986.
Pacifism has thus been described simply as antiwarism or as commitment to nonviolence. Princeton university press, 1989 which also strongly advocates a certain kind of pacifism to which i will return and jan narveson, pacifism. It is my intention to attempt to define pacifism, in its engagement and concept, as a necessary requisite of war and military action, following a phrase used over a hundred years ago by franz rosenzweig when speaking of pacifism as necessary equipment of war. Pacifism is often painted into a corner as an absolute rejection of all violence and war.
Taking a unique approach that emphasizes careful reasoning, this cuttingedge reader is structured. Its central thesis is that pacifism is an incoherent doctrine. Sep 10, 2015 in this, the first major philosophical study of contingent pacifism, larry may offers a new account of pacifism from within the just war tradition. Philosophers took up pacifism as an object for philosophical analysis. The first major anthology to survey the field of moral and ethical issues concerning war and peace, this text traces debates from cicero and augustine to kosovo and iraq today. Peace is easiest to define dialectically as the opposite of war or violence.
Of all the attitudes and theories associated with or identified as pacifism, only the doctrine that everyone ought not to resist violence with force is of philosophical interest, and it is logically incoherent. List of books and articles about pacifism online research. Pacifism, the principled opposition to war and violence as a means of settling disputes. It is an important contribution to the understanding of the pacifist tradition in japan and shows its development since the end of the nineteenth century. If we say that the principle of pacifism is the principle that all and only pacifists have a duty of not opposing violence with force, we get into a very odd situation. Lewis vaughn is the author or coauthor of numerous books, including living philosophy, second edition oup, 2017, bioethics, third edition oup, 2016, and philosophy here and now, second edition oup, 2015. Principled pacifism holds that at some point along the spectrum from war to interpersonal physical violence, such violence becomes morally wrong. According to the most radical prohibition against war, there are no circumstances in which it is morally permissible to wage a war. An introduction to philosophical analysis 4th edition.
1231 467 756 691 79 1371 699 524 1333 1652 225 827 54 1398 1351 889 202 1586 1091 1323 1203 1129 571 1683 1595 157 231 1081 298 1673 1156 878 1485 521 282 650 62 706 928 1060